PROTAGION
  • Proteges
    • Now What?
    • Career Support Guide
    • Career Goals >
      • Promotion / Raise
      • New Skills
      • Further Qualifications
      • Moving Countries
      • Switching: Consult/Contract/Startup
      • Transition: Specialism/Profession
      • Managing a Business
      • Portfolio Career
      • Purpose & Meaning
      • CPD
      • (Conference 1-5 Mar '21)
    • Example Professions >
      • Accounting
      • Actuarial
      • Asset & Investment Management
      • Risk Management
      • And more... >
        • Talent Management for Professionals
    • Our Services
    • Courses
  • Mentors
    • Encore Mentor
    • Featured Subset >
      • Anne - Australia
      • Boniswa - S Africa
      • Bradley - UK
      • Hafsa - S Africa
      • Lee - Hong Kong
      • Lusani - S Africa
      • Margaret - S Africa
      • Michael - S Africa
      • Natasha - UK
      • Nikki - UK
      • Sumit - India
      • Trevor - UK
      • And More on our Protege Platform...
  • Subscribe
  • Platform Login
    • Login
    • Sign Up: Free
  • Stories
    • Our Stories & Articles
    • Our Principles
    • Books
We help professionals achieve their career goals
OUR STORIES
Over 150 career-related articles and counting... Scroll down to read
NEED MORE CAREER SUPPORT? Our professional mentors & coaches are here to help
Join our in-a-group facilitated sessions & explore your career questions with us​
SUBSCRIBE TO JOIN OUR
IN-A-GROUP SESSIONS

In Pursuit of Knowledge: Specialising vs Generalising as a Career Strategy

2/11/2017

0 Comments

 
Last month I completed reading a book called "Sprint"* which is about quick prototyping of new ideas, and testing them with customers to gauge their reactions before spending too much time or money on building them. This agile process allows course-correcting based on market reaction. The book is written by three guys from Google Ventures, and is very much focused on business innovation, and how to speed up the learning process. It contains a range of examples, including Slack, FitStar and Savioke. While not the authors' intention, the section on prototyping-in-a-day sparked my thinking about careers, which is what this post is about.

Prototyping
First, some additional detail on prototyping. One chapter described building a prototype like a movie set. In effect, this is hacking a solution that offers just enough so that it appears real to target customers i.e. temporary simulation rather than long-term quality. It must be realistic to prompt genuine reactions: a level such that the customers you're testing it with forget their surroundings and just react (like a movie audience). The book shows this "just enough" in the form of a steep cumulative graph, where, within a day, you can get to a product / brochure / service experience that isn't perfect, but also doesn't take the huge time investment to improve it further. It is an application of the 80/20 rule or "Pareto principle".
Picture
Learning new skills
I began thinking about this in the context of learning and applying new skills, and the career distinction between being (i) a manager and generalist or (ii) a technical/functional specialist. As a manager, you need to be familiar with a variety of different disciplines. This is both to support your own team members who deal with each specialism, and also to see opportunities across disciplines and interface with varied functions across your wider organisation. In this context, it can be dangerous to be too wedded to your own discipline that you started from as you can miss the bigger picture. As you rise in seniority, you need to be willing to learn new skills at the same time as trusting those who work for you. The new skills also help you to know enough to challenge where necessary. I worked with someone who wore his lack of knowledge about some of the areas he was responsible for as a badge of honour, proudly declaring his disdain for expertise in those functions. While he probably saw this as bravado, you can imagine how those in his team with that domain knowledge felt when their leader spoke that way...
One advantage of "some knowledge" is that it means you are more flexible to change, and don't unnecessarily rush to defend your discipline at the slightest criticism. It is often said it takes 10 000 hours to become an expert at something - once you've spent even half that time, you become very invested in protecting it...

The advantages of expertise
Nevertheless, working towards being an expert is a very valid career strategy, especially in technical or scientific areas. For example, knowing a lot about your specialism is far more likely to lead you to a scientific breakthrough or a Nobel Prize. And, some doctors much prefer to be highly specialised (like a paediatric anaesthetist, for example) rather than a General Practitioner (GP) although, admittedly, this is very much down to individual preference.
Anesthesiologist
Tourists on an open-top bus tour of Paris, France
Another aspect worth considering is the audience you're engaging with: expertise is relative. Your rudimentary ability to speak your second language may impress your fellow travellers while on holiday, but the locals won't think you're an expert. Similarly, it's definitely possible to appear knowledgeable for a limited time, but after a while, others may start to see that there is no depth behind the jargon and rote explanations you give. Both of these support the argument for growing your expertise.

Focus vs flexibility
It is worthwhile bearing in mind that being an expert at many things is almost impossible, which makes the choice of what to specialise in even more daunting, as you could end up focusing on the wrong areas. Being "good enough" at a number of things is a much safer strategy than aiming for perfection in only one area. And, once you've spent sufficient time to confirm that you enjoy or value these new areas, this allows you more choices of what to become better at (or switch across to if needed).

If being a manager is your goal, then you could also view managerial skills as ones to practice - in effect aiming to be a specialist in those (which would make you a better generalist!)... This includes skills like commercial acumen, communication, networking, building support etc. An analogy here is a sports team manager, who effectively specialises in managing the players and how they work together. 

Consulting: depth vs breadth
Another area we've seen this come up is within the consulting industry. Working with our members has shown us that there are two main strategies for career success as a consultant: depth and breadth. The "depth" strategy involves picking a new/emerging area, becoming your consultancy's expert in that area, and signalling your expertise within your organisation and externally. This will make it likely you are always on projects requiring that specific expertise (as you will be seen as the go-to person). It is important to choose an area that is growing and will remain big for some time, and keep those skills relevant and up-to-date. Examples here from the financial services industry might include cyber security, fintech / insurtech, automation, specific tax knowledge, new accounting standards, or emerging regulatory requirements.

The other strategy of "breadth" involves bringing new projects to the consultancy by networking widely, and understanding what your customers' needs are, spotting opportunities to provide solutions across specialisms. This requires good knowledge across a wider range of topics. The breadth of your understanding helps you to talk with Boards and senior executives, and translate your knowledge into how to solve their challenges. Bringing significant revenue to a consultancy is a great way to get yourself noticed, and promoted.

An Exercise For You

For each of your key skills, where would you plot yourself (relative to others) on the novice-to-expert continuum? And, in the limited time you have to improve these skills, are you investing wisely into the ones which will lead you to the best outcomes for your career? 
Are there other skills which might benefit you to know more about, that you can practise in a safe environment before committing?

Perhaps the best approach is to spend time upfront on learning how to learn quickly and efficiently, so that you can reskill and adapt as circumstances change?
* PROTAGION is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. The links with * participate in this programme.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Follow @Protagion

    Author

    Bradley Shearer
    ​Founder of Protagion
    My Personal Journey
    I'd love to hear your stories

    SHARE YOUR
    STORY WITH ME

    Categories

    All
    Active Career Management
    Branching Out
    Connection
    Consulting
    Contracting
    Future Of Work
    Inspiration
    Leadership
    Learning
    Mentoring
    Non Executive Directors (NEDs)
    Personal Journeys
    Professions
    Psychology
    Real Life Examples
    Role Options
    Routes To The Top

    Tweets by protagion

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017

    RSS Feed

"NOW WHAT?" - a common question our visitors ask...
​WE CAN HELP!
Examples of common career goals, with resources for each: promotion, new skills, further study/qualifications, moving countries, switching into consulting / contracting / startup, transition to new specialism or profession, managing a business, portfolio career, purpose & meaning, CPD, and more... 


Follow @Protagion
Home / Proteges
> ​Services
> Subscribe
> CPD
​​

​Mentors

Our Stories / Blog

Sign Up to use our System
​
​
Privacy Policy​
Career Development and Talent Management for professionals: accountants, actuaries, analysts, asset managers, bankers, CFAs, data scientists, engineers, investment managers, risk managers, and more...
Protagion currently offers services in English, although some of our mentors & coaches speak other languages too. ​Please email us if you have any questions.
Picture

​© 2017-2023 PROTAGION LIMITED (10721032) is a company registered in England and Wales.
Registered Address: 128 City Road, London, United Kingdom, EC1V 2NX
Photos used under Creative Commons from Pjposullivan1, paul.horsefield, flazingo_photos
  • Proteges
    • Now What?
    • Career Support Guide
    • Career Goals >
      • Promotion / Raise
      • New Skills
      • Further Qualifications
      • Moving Countries
      • Switching: Consult/Contract/Startup
      • Transition: Specialism/Profession
      • Managing a Business
      • Portfolio Career
      • Purpose & Meaning
      • CPD
      • (Conference 1-5 Mar '21)
    • Example Professions >
      • Accounting
      • Actuarial
      • Asset & Investment Management
      • Risk Management
      • And more... >
        • Talent Management for Professionals
    • Our Services
    • Courses
  • Mentors
    • Encore Mentor
    • Featured Subset >
      • Anne - Australia
      • Boniswa - S Africa
      • Bradley - UK
      • Hafsa - S Africa
      • Lee - Hong Kong
      • Lusani - S Africa
      • Margaret - S Africa
      • Michael - S Africa
      • Natasha - UK
      • Nikki - UK
      • Sumit - India
      • Trevor - UK
      • And More on our Protege Platform...
  • Subscribe
  • Platform Login
    • Login
    • Sign Up: Free
  • Stories
    • Our Stories & Articles
    • Our Principles
    • Books